What We Stand For


When you think of family, what comes to mind?

Trust     Loyalty    Security    Commitment    Support

At the Maguire Family of Dealerships, we want to do more than just fulfill your vehicle needs. We want to make you a part of our family.

We strive to provide our customers with the best possible car buying experience.  Buying a car shouldn't be a painful process. It should be enjoyable. You should be able to walk away feeling happy and relaxed.

At the Maguire Family of Dealerships, we can guarantee you will walk away satisfied.

The prices you see are the prices you get. No hidden costs, no tacked on fees. All discounts and incentives are already included. So, you know you are getting the best possible price around.

In addition, our sales people are non-commissioned. This means that they are paid based on your satisfaction rather than how much you spent on the vehicle. Instead, they can focus on you and your needs as a customer.  

So, sit back, relax and feel free to browse our online inventory.  If you would like to request more information about vehicles, set up a test drive or inquire about financing don't hesitate to contact us!

If you don't see what you are looking for, try our easy to use CarFinder option located under the Vehicles tab. Fill out the short form and we will contact you as soon as your desired vehicle arrives!

Or, if you would rather discuss your options with any of our friendly sales staff in person, click on our locations option found under the About Us tab for interactive driving directions as well as other contact information.

We look forward to serving you!

                                                         -Tim & Phil Maguire

About Maguire Subaru Dealership - A New & Used Subaru Car Dealer in Ithaca Near Syracuse, Elmira, Vestal and Cortland, NY

Maguire Subaru is your local Subaru dealer in Ithaca near Syracuse, Elmira, Vestal & Cortland, NY. We offer a large variety of new Subaru cars but also an extensive inventory of used cars. With such a diverse selection to choose from an a friendly and experienced staff, you will be sure to find the car you've been waiting for.

Think you may need car financing? Don't worry about searching all over town because we offer auto loans and Subaru leases right here at our Ithaca Maguire Subaru Dealership. Give our staff a call or fill out our finance application online to start the process started.

Whether you have a new car that needs maintenance or a used car that requires some auto repair, our skilled technicians and Subaru parts professionals can get the job done with accuracy and timeliness.

At Maguire Subaru, we always strive to provide the best price and service to ensure you an excellent experience if you are buying a car, having one serviced or even purchasing parts. We understand that it's hard to take a business' word, so why don't you see for yourself that we will be our number one destination for all your auto needs? Stop by our car dealership today at 320 Elmira Rd, Ithaca, New York. We can't wait to meet you!

Maguire Subaru

320 Elmira Road
Directions Ithaca, NY 14850

  • Call or Text Sales: (607)273-8585
  • Service: (607)273-8585
  • Parts: (607)273-8585


  • Monday 08:00am-08:00pm
  • Tuesday 08:00am-08:00pm
  • Wednesday 08:00am-08:00pm
  • Thursday 08:00am-08:00pm
  • Friday 08:00am-06:00pm
  • Saturday 08:00am-06:00pm
  • Sunday Closed

Dealership Contact Info:

Maguire Subaru 
320 Elmira Road
Dealership: Directions
) $javascript.push ('https://app.livemarketshoppers.com/fullthrottlelims.js?s=463')
; ;